Med-Surg · chapter 4 · Clinical Judgment in the Nursing Process
Critical Thinking and the Nursing Process
The 14 things this section of the textbook says that you are most likely to be asked about — quoted word for word, not retold. Then 9 practice questions with the reasoning.
Key points
Nursing process purpose
The steps of the nursing process provide direction for nurses when making patient care decisions.
Safe decisions and outcomes
Each decision affects the patient’s health status, and safe and effective decisions by nurses enhance patient outcome s (Nibbelink Brewer, 2018).
Nursing diagnoses scope
It is important to note that nursing diagnoses differ from medical diagnoses: they are broader and holistic, encompassing aspects of physical health in addition to psychosocial, cultural, and environmental factors that affect the patient’s health.
Nursing diagnosis focus
A nursing diagnosis is not the actual medical condition but rather the problems related to the medical condition.
ADPIE steps
The nursing process consists of five steps: assessment, diagnosis, planning, implementation, and evaluation (also known as ADPIE), each of which is discussed in more detail in the following sections.
Assessment data sources
When providing nursing care, assessment includes gathering data from the patient, the patient’s medical record, the patient’s family members or caregivers, and physical assessment findings.
Assessment pattern recognition
The nurse acknowledges the expected data, focuses on unexpected findings, and looks for patterns in the data to assist with the formation of a nursing diagnosis and an individualized plan of care.
Diagnosis development
The analysis of data provides direction for the nurse to identify or determine the patient’s current or potential problem(s) and develop a problem-based nursing diagnosis.
Care plan foundation
Prioritization of the established diagnoses is the foundation of the patient’s plan of care, which leads to the next step in the nursing process: planning.
Planning outcomes goals
For each diagnosis, the nurse identifies outcomes and goals that will enhance the patient’s condition and health status.
Implementation actions
To achieve the prioritized outcomes, the nurse implements a series of planned actions, or nursing interventions.
Evaluation purpose
Once the nursing interventions have been implemented, the nurse evaluates the patient’s current health status to determine if the actions were effective and if the patient outcomes were achieved.
Cyclic care modification
This evaluation may result in modifications of the diagnosis, plan, or nursing actions, and reflects the circular nature of the nursing process.
Nurses detecting changes
Many times, nurses are the ones tasked with making clinical decisions that will significantly affect the lives of their patients because they are often the first to notice changes and recognize potential problems.
Terms to know
- clinical judgment
- The thought process that allows nurses to arrive at a conclusion based on objective and subjective information about a patient—and thereby achieve positive patient outcomes—is called clinical judgment.
- nursing process
- The nursing process consists of five steps: assessment, diagnosis, planning, implementation, and evaluation (also known as ADPIE), each of which is discussed in more detail in the following sections.
- assessment
- When providing nursing care, assessment includes gathering data from the patient, the patient’s medical record, the patient’s family members or caregivers, and physical assessment findings.
- nursing interventions
- To achieve the prioritized outcomes, the nurse implements a series of planned actions, or nursing interventions.
- NPO
- Based on these findings, the nurse decides to make the patient NPO (nil per us, which means “nothing by mouth”) as a safety precaution to prevent aspiration.
- Clinical Judgment Measurement Model (CJMM)
- The Clinical Judgment Measurement Model (CJMM) was developed by the National Council of State Boards of Nursing (NCSBN) to allow nurse educators to teach, assess, and measure the development of clinical judgment skills in nursing students and new graduates taking the National Council Licensure Examination (NCLEX-RN).
Practice questions
Stuck on select-all-that-apply? How to take them one option at a time.
The graded version needs JavaScript. Every question is below anyway, with the answer and why.
Every question here, with the answer
At the end of a cardiology clinic visit, you review the patient's blood pressure measurements from the past three visits. They have gradually risen to above-normal values. Which assessment entry best supports an individualized plan of care?
- Blood pressure is above normal today; another visit is needed before the existing measurements can be assessed for a pattern.
- Blood pressure is above normal today; assessment is based on the current reading without comparison to previous visits.
- Blood pressure readings have increased; interpretation of these findings will be deferred until a medical diagnosis is established.
- Blood pressure has gradually risen across three visits to above-normal values; this unexpected trend will inform the care plan.
Answer: Blood pressure has gradually risen across three visits to above-normal values; this unexpected trend will inform the care plan.
The assessment should recognize the unexpected pattern across visits and use it to guide individualized care. Considering only today's reading misses the trend, while waiting for another visit or a medical diagnosis unnecessarily postpones analysis of data already available.
At 0800, you begin an admission assessment. The patient and a family caregiver are available, and you can access the medical record. Which approaches should you use to build the assessment documentation? Select all that apply.
- Gather relevant information from the patient's medical record.
- Gather relevant information from the family caregiver.
- Use only the patient and medical record as sources, excluding caregiver information from the assessment.
- Include information reported by the patient alongside physical assessment findings.
- Limit the assessment to physical findings, saving the patient's reported concerns for a later care-plan review.
Answer: Gather relevant information from the patient's medical record., Gather relevant information from the family caregiver., Include information reported by the patient alongside physical assessment findings.
The section identifies the patient, medical record, family members or caregivers, and physical findings as assessment sources. Restricting the entry to physical findings leaves out subjective information, and excluding the caregiver omits another source explicitly included in the assessment process.
At 1400, a patient with previously diagnosed hypertension arrives in the emergency department reporting 10/10 chest pain. You are updating the prioritized problems in the care plan. Which entry best reflects the patient's current situation?
- Retain the previous hypertension-focused priorities until a new medical diagnosis is confirmed.
- List hypertension and the chest-pain concern without ranking them until more assessment data are available.
- Keep hypertension as the first priority because it is an established diagnosis; add chest pain below it.
- Prioritize the potential myocardial infarction over treatment of the underlying hypertension.
Answer: Prioritize the potential myocardial infarction over treatment of the underlying hypertension.
The patient's current presentation changes the priorities: the potential myocardial infarction takes precedence over the underlying hypertension. Keeping the established diagnosis first, leaving the problems unranked, or waiting for confirmation fails to apply the section's situation-based prioritization.
Near the end of your shift, you evaluate a patient after prescribed pain medication and find that the pain has not been relieved. You document the patient's response. Which care-plan updates are supported by the section? Select all that apply.
- Document persistent pain but leave the interventions unchanged for the next shift to evaluate.
- Revise the plan to include advocating for a change in the medication order.
- Use completion of the prescribed medication administration as the evaluation of the pain outcome.
- Revise the plan to include a nonpharmacological approach, such as position change or distraction.
- Update the nursing diagnosis to reflect persistent pain without revisiting the plan or interventions.
Answer: Revise the plan to include advocating for a change in the medication order., Revise the plan to include a nonpharmacological approach, such as position change or distraction.
When prescribed medication does not relieve pain, the section directs the nurse to revisit the plan and add interventions, including advocating for an order change or using nonpharmacological methods. Completing an intervention is not evidence that the outcome was achieved. Recording persistent pain, deferring changes, or revising only the diagnosis does not make the needed adjustment to the pain-management plan.
At 0900 in a cardiology clinic, you review the last three visit records and see the patient’s blood pressure has gradually risen to above normal values. You are completing the assessment portion of the nursing process. What is the best way to handle this finding?
- Identify the rising blood pressure as an unexpected pattern and use it to guide the nursing diagnosis and individualized plan of care.
- Treat the current blood pressure as the only usable finding because prior visits are not part of this assessment.
- Record the trend as routine and expected because gradual changes do not affect the nursing process.
- Skip assessment analysis and enter hypertension as the nursing diagnosis.
Answer: Identify the rising blood pressure as an unexpected pattern and use it to guide the nursing diagnosis and individualized plan of care.
Assessment is not just data collection; the nurse analyzes relevant data, notices unexpected findings, and looks for patterns. The other options ignore the trend, label it routine, or jump to a diagnosis without assessment analysis.
At 1100, after assessment data are reviewed, a patient receives a medical diagnosis of hypertension. You need to identify problem-based nursing diagnoses for the plan of care. Which entry best fits the nursing process described in the section?
- Open the blocked vessel to limit cardiac tissue damage.
- Hypertension.
- Gradual rise in blood pressure measurements over three clinic visits.
- Decreased cardiac output; risk for impaired cerebral tissue perfusion; activity intolerance.
Answer: Decreased cardiac output; risk for impaired cerebral tissue perfusion; activity intolerance.
Nursing diagnoses describe patient problems related to the medical condition and are broader than simply naming the condition. Hypertension is the medical diagnosis, the blood pressure trend is assessment data, and opening the blocked vessel is a planned outcome from the chest pain example.
At 1500, two nurses are reconciling a shared care plan before handoff. They want the plan to support consistent care rather than create duplicate work. Which uses of the nursing process match the section’s stated benefits? Select all that apply.
- Use the plan to avoid modifying care after evaluation.
- Use the plan to decrease omissions and duplications in care.
- Use the plan as a guide so all involved staff provide consistent and responsive care.
- Use the plan to keep each discipline working separately on the patient’s problems.
- Use the plan to reduce continuity between providers and institutions.
Answer: Use the plan to decrease omissions and duplications in care., Use the plan as a guide so all involved staff provide consistent and responsive care.
The section identifies fewer omissions and duplications and a guide for staff to provide consistent, responsive care as benefits. The other options contradict the described benefits: the process encourages collaboration, supports modification, and improves continuity.
At 1800, you evaluate a patient after giving the prescribed pain medication, and the patient’s pain is not relieved. According to the evaluation step, what should you do next in the plan of care?
- Replace the nursing diagnosis with the medical condition causing the pain.
- Continue the same plan unchanged because evaluation happens only after all diagnoses are resolved.
- Return to the plan and modify it with additional interventions, such as advocating for a medication order change or using nonpharmacological methods.
- Document that the expected outcome was achieved because the ordered medication was administered.
Answer: Return to the plan and modify it with additional interventions, such as advocating for a medication order change or using nonpharmacological methods.
Evaluation determines whether actions were effective; if the outcome is not achieved, the care plan may need modification. The other options confuse implementation with success, prevent needed revision, or substitute a medical diagnosis for nursing problem-solving.
At 1030 on a medical-surgical unit, a patient develops facial droop and dysarthria and cannot move their arm. Which actions from the section’s clinical judgment example should the nurse take? Select all that apply.
- Document only hygiene care and bed linen changes because those are the nurse’s main role.
- Wait to act until a physician gives orders, because nursing decisions are task-oriented.
- Treat the findings as expected data and continue the current plan without change.
- Notify the stroke emergency responders according to the institution’s policy.
- Perform a neurological assessment.
Answer: Notify the stroke emergency responders according to the institution’s policy., Perform a neurological assessment.
The example states that the nurse uses clinical judgment to assess neurologic status and notify stroke responders per policy. Waiting passively, treating new deficits as expected, or reducing the nurse’s role to basic tasks contradicts the section’s description of contemporary nursing judgment.
Where every quote comes from
Section 4.1 Critical Thinking and the Nursing Process of Medical-Surgical Nursing by Christy Bowen, Bridget Carey, Jessica Palozie, Maren Reinholdt, OpenStax, 2024. Read the whole section free at openstax.org.
The textbook is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. This page quotes it word for word and adds the headings, the order and the practice questions; references to the book's figures and stray spaces left by its formatting are removed. The page is shared under the same licence. Nothing here is sold.