Fundamentals · chapter 13 · Diagnosis and Planning: Analyzing, Prioritizing, and Generating Solutions
Evolution of Nursing Diagnosis
The 14 things this section of the textbook says that you are most likely to be asked about — quoted word for word, not retold. Then 6 practice questions with the reasoning.
Key points
Common nursing language
The development of nursing diagnosis began with the need for a common language to communicate across the profession.
Nursing diagnosis statements
In carefully constructed, concise statements, the nursing diagnosis identifies patient issues (clinical and psychosocial) and articulates potential causes of the problem.
Patient-specific needs
Changing the medical diagnosis to the nursing diagnosis allows the nurse to identify a patient’s specific needs—which, in the case of a patient who has diabetes, may be unstable glucose levels.
Care planning foundation
This problem-solving approach to articulating patient problems or needs is the basis for planning care and interventions, as it lays the foundation for critical thinking.
ANA practice standards
These five steps of the nursing process are also named by the American Nurses Association (ANA) as the approved Standards of Practice to designate a “competent level of nursing care... and forms the foundation of the nurse’s decision-making” (American Nurses Association [ANA], 2015a).
NANDA diagnosis list
In the 1970s, the North American Nursing Diagnosis Association (NANDA) developed a list of nursing diagnoses, which were delineated, patient-focused statements formed through this nursing process and selected through patient assessment.
NANDA decision framework
The NANDA diagnosis list utilizes a problem-solving approach that helps provide individualized nursing care to patients. In short, it provides a framework for decision-making based on collected data related to the patient’s condition.
Autonomous nursing profession
Nursing diagnosis became the foundation of what makes nursing a distinct and autonomous profession in health care.
Multiple patient needs
The dynamic ability of nursing diagnoses enables nurses to address multiple facets of their patients’ healthcare needs, including clinical, pathophysiological, psychosocial, and environmental.
ANA nurse role
Within the Standards of Practice, the ANA defines the job of the nurse as including “the diagnosis and treatment of human responses to actual or potential health problems” (ANA, 2015b).
Patient support network
It is important to note when engaging in this process that nurses do not only consider the patient themselves but all those involved in providing care. Families, significant others, loved ones, and perhaps even friends can all be part of the patient’s support network.
Care planning interventions
The problem-solving approach to care planning gives the nurse a clear starting point to assign interventions and evaluate their effectiveness.
Dynamic clinical judgment
As a profession, nurses realized they needed to develop critical thinking and clinical judgment skills that are required to dynamically revise nursing diagnoses as needed.
CJMM purpose
The Clinical Judgment Measurement Model (CJMM) is the latest framework developed by the National Council of State Boards of Nursing (NCSBN) to aid in identifying nursing-focused clinical problems.
Terms to know
- nursing diagnosis
- A methodical way to provide and evaluate appropriate patient care is called nursing diagnosis.
- critical thinking
- As you learned in 12.4 Cognitive Process for Analyzing Assessment Data, critical thinking describes a process of thought that uses structured methods of observation, reasoning, and thought to make educated and rational decisions.
- NANDA-I
- The organization is now known as NANDA-I, whose purpose is still to facilitate the development, modification, distribution, and use of standardized nursing diagnostic terminology.
- Taxonomy II
- Taxonomy II, the current classification method for listing nursing diagnoses, has three levels: domains, classes, and nursing diagnosis.
- Tanner’s Clinical Judgement Model (CJM)
- Tanner’s Clinical Judgement Model (CJM) is a helpful framework that offers a different articulated perspective to the problem-solving approach for developing nursing diagnoses.
- Clinical Judgment Measurement Model (CJMM)
- The Clinical Judgment Measurement Model (CJMM) is the latest framework developed by the National Council of State Boards of Nursing (NCSBN) to aid in identifying nursing-focused clinical problems.
- Recognize Cues
- Recognize Cues can be defined as identifying relevant clinical data using multiple sources available to the nurse, including the presenting scenario, medical history, vital signs, nursing assessment, and laboratory values, then extracting important clinical data from these sources.
- Analyze Cues
- Analyze Cues can be defined as taking the data that have been collected and interpreting it using an existing knowledge base.
Practice questions
Stuck on select-all-that-apply? How to take them one option at a time.
The graded version needs JavaScript. Every question is below anyway, with the answer and why.
Every question here, with the answer
A nurse is caring for a patient with type 2 diabetes mellitus and wants to move from a medical diagnosis to a nursing diagnosis that can guide an individualized plan of care. Which statement best reflects the nursing diagnosis approach described in the section?
- The provider will determine the patient’s glucose problem.
- Risk for unstable blood glucose levels related to insufficient diabetes management.
- The patient has type 2 diabetes mellitus.
- The patient is a diabetic.
Answer: Risk for unstable blood glucose levels related to insufficient diabetes management.
The correct option changes a broad medical description into a patient-focused nursing diagnosis that identifies a specific need and a potential cause. The other options either label the patient, state only the medical diagnosis, or shift the nurse’s decision-making role away from nursing diagnosis.
A nurse has implemented a care plan and is now evaluating whether the plan should continue, be modified, or be discontinued. Which questions are appropriate for the nurse to ask during this evaluation step? Select all that apply.
- Does anything about the plan need to be changed?
- Is the patient making progress toward the intended results?
- Was the goal met—fully, partially, or not at all?
- Can the plan continue as planned?
- Which domain and class should be assigned before any evaluation occurs?
Answer: Does anything about the plan need to be changed?, Is the patient making progress toward the intended results?, Was the goal met—fully, partially, or not at all?, Can the plan continue as planned?
Evaluation focuses on the patient’s progress toward the desired outcome and whether the plan should continue, change, or stop. Assigning a domain and class is related to organizing nursing diagnoses, not evaluating the effectiveness of an implemented plan.
A nurse enters a room after a vital sign monitor alarms. The patient is pale, diaphoretic, sitting in a tripod position, and says, “I can’t catch my breath, and my chest hurts.” Which priority hypothesis best reflects the CJMM approach in this acute situation?
- The patient’s comfort domain should be classified before deciding what to do.
- The patient may have acute respiratory distress or cardiac compromise.
- The patient’s primary issue is that the plan of care needs more time to work.
- The patient should first be evaluated for readiness to learn.
Answer: The patient may have acute respiratory distress or cardiac compromise.
In an acute situation, the nurse prioritizes breathing and circulation concerns using the ABCs framework. The other options delay priority thinking or focus on classification, time, or teaching rather than the urgent cues described.
A nurse is planning care for a patient and wants to include the patient’s support network as described in the nursing process. Which people may appropriately be included as part of this collaborative process? Select all that apply.
- Family members
- Only the nurse, because nursing diagnosis is an autonomous function
- Friends
- Loved ones
- Significant others
Answer: Family members, Friends, Loved ones, Significant others
The section emphasizes that nurses consider not only the patient but also others involved in care and support. Limiting the process to only the nurse ignores the collaborative role of the patient’s support network.
A new nurse is caring for a complex patient whose condition changes unexpectedly and does not fit neatly into a ready-made diagnosis. Which framework best supports the nurse in dynamically revising the nursing diagnosis through critical thinking and clinical judgment?
- The Clinical Judgment Measurement Model, because it supports flexible clinical judgment for changing patient needs.
- NANDA-I only, because ready-made diagnoses always fit complex patient needs.
- Taxonomy II only, because arranging diagnoses alphabetically solves unexpected changes.
- The ANA Standards of Practice, because they eliminate the need to revise nursing diagnoses.
Answer: The Clinical Judgment Measurement Model, because it supports flexible clinical judgment for changing patient needs.
The section explains that complex and unexpected patient changes require nurses to think critically and revise nursing diagnoses dynamically, leading to the CJMM. The other options overstate or misapply NANDA-I, Taxonomy II, or ANA standards.
A nurse has collected patient data and is using the CJMM skill of Analyze Cues. Which actions match this cognitive skill? Select all that apply.
- Recognizing patterns in the clinical data
- Determining whether patient outcomes were fully or partially met
- Interpreting collected data using an existing knowledge base
- Organizing the clinical data
- Generating hypotheses regarding the clinical cues collected
Answer: Recognizing patterns in the clinical data, Interpreting collected data using an existing knowledge base, Organizing the clinical data, Generating hypotheses regarding the clinical cues collected
Analyze Cues involves interpreting and organizing collected data, recognizing patterns, and generating hypotheses. Determining whether outcomes were met belongs to Evaluate Outcomes, not Analyze Cues.
Where every quote comes from
Section 13.1 Evolution of Nursing Diagnosis of Fundamentals of Nursing by Christy Bowen, Lindsay Draper, Heather Moore, OpenStax, 2024. Read the whole section free at openstax.org.
The textbook is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. This page quotes it word for word and adds the headings, the order and the practice questions; references to the book's figures and stray spaces left by its formatting are removed. The page is shared under the same licence. Nothing here is sold.